Andy Driscoll
A quick question for the rugby brains out there. i've watched two games of rugby on the box today and in both games a retreating pack was penalised at a scrum (the ref's arm went out soon after the ball went in). One ref gave the penalty at the point where the scrum finally collapsed, while the other ref (Steve Walsh) took the penalty back to where the scrum engaged. The penalties were identical, so which ref was correct?